First year: 2013
All-Time Regular Season Record: 107-39
All-Time Postseason Record: 11-6
Last UFA Postseason: 2024/Central Division Championship — def. Chicago (18-17 2OT); lost to Minnesota (23-14)
Central Division Champions: 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018
UFA Champions: 2018
| Year | Record | Goals | Goals Against |
| 2013 | 13-3* | 368 | 318 |
| 2014 | z- 12-2 | 334 | 210 |
| 2015 | z- 13-1 | 365 | 237 |
| 2016 | z- 14-0 | 366 | 231 |
| 2017 | z- 12-2 | 309 | 259 |
| 2018† | z- 12-2 | 348 | 250 |
| 2019 | 6-6 | 250 | 222 |
| 2021 | 7-5 | 257 | 222 |
| 2022 | 6-6 | 232 | 233 |
| 2023 | 4-8 | 229 | 226 |
| 2024 | 8-4* | 263 | 213 |
*- Clinched playoffs; z- Won regular season division title; †- Won UFA title
2013
Record: 13-3, Finished 2nd in Midwest Division
Points/Game: 23.0 (6th out of 12)
Opp. Points/Game: 19.9 (3rd out of 12)
Assists Leader: Dave Wiseman (59)
Goals Leader: Scott Richgels (44)
Blocks Leader: Dave Wiseman (31)
| DATE | AWAY TEAM | HOME TEAM | SCORE | RECORD |
| APR 20 | MADISON | CHICAGO | 22-21 | 1-0 (W) |
| APR 21 | MADISON | DETROIT | 24-25 | 1-1 (L) |
| APR 27 | MADISON | MINNESOTA | 22-20 | 2-1 (W) |
| MAY 3 | MINNESOTA | MADISON | 15-19 | 3-1 (W) |
| MAY 12 | CHICAGO | MADISON | 16-15 | 3-2 (L) |
| MAY 18 | DETROIT | MADISON | 16-26 | 4-2 (W) |
| MAY 24 | MINNESOTA | MADISON | 23-27 | 5-2 (W) |
| JUN 2 | CINCINNATI | MADISON | 20-26 | 6-2 (W) |
| JUN 7 | MADISON | MINNESOTA | 25-24 | 7-2 (W) |
| JUN 15 | MADISON | CINCINNATI | 21-23 | 7-3 (L) |
| JUN 16 | MADISON | INDIANAPOLIS | 24-22 | 8-3 (W) |
| JUN 22 | INDIANAPOLIS | MADISON | 16-20 | 9-3 (W) |
| JUN 29 | MADISON | CHICAGO | 15-13 | 10-3 (W) |
| JUN 30 | MADISON | DETROIT | 29-22 | 11-3 (W) |
| JUL 6 | CINCINNATI | MADISON | 18-28 | 12-3 (W) |
| JUL 14 | INDIANAPOLIS | MADISON | 23-25 | 13-3 (W) |
| JUL 27 | INDIANAPOLIS | MADISON | 15-18 | 14-3 (W) |
| AUG 3 | MADISON | CHICAGO | 21-15 | 15-3 (W) |
| AUG 4 | MADISON | TORONTO | 14-16 | 15-4 (L) |
2014
Record: 12-2, Finished 1st in Midwest Division
Points/Game: 26.1 (2nd out of 17)
Opp. Points/Game: 16.5 (1st out of 17)
Assists Leader: Tom Annen (35)
Goals Leader: David Schleicher (33)
Blocks Leader: Peter Graffy (49)
| DATE | AWAY TEAM | HOME TEAM | SCORE | RECORD |
| APR 12 | MADISON | CINCINNATI | 25-16 | 1-0 (W) |
| APR 13 | MADISON | INDIANAPOLIS | 26-21 | 2-0 (W) |
| APR 19 | MADISON | DETROIT | 34-9 | 3-0 (W) |
| APR 25 | MADISON | MINNESOTA | 20-23 | 3-1 (L) |
| MAY 3 | INDIANAPOLIS | MADISON | 18-27 | 4-1 (W) |
| MAY 9 | MINNESOTA | MADISON | 15-22 | 5-1 (W) |
| MAY 23 | MADISON | CHICAGO | 14-15 | 5-2 (L) |
| MAY 24 | CHICAGO | MADISON | 12-15 | 6-2 (W) |
| MAY 31 | MADISON | CINCINNATI | 29-12 | 7-2 (W) |
| JUN 7 | MADISON | INDIANAPOLIS | 23-12 | 8-2 (W) |
| JUN 8 | CINCINNATI | MADISON | 15-28 | 9-2 (W) |
| JUN 14 | MINNESOTA | MADISON | 15-23 | 10-2 (W) |
| JUN 20 | CHICAGO | MADISON | 19-24 | 11-2 (W) |
| JUN 28 | DETROIT | MADISON | 9-28 | 12-2 (W) |
| JUL 19 | INDIANAPOLIS | MADISON | 16-25 | 13-2 (W) |
| JUL 26 | MADISON | SAN JOSE | 20-23 | 13-3 (L) |
2015
Record: 13-1, Finished 1st in Midwest Division
Points/Game: 26.1 (4th out of 25)
Opp. Points/Game: 16.9 (1st out of 25)
Assists Leader: Andrew Meshnick (31)
Goals Leader: Dave Wiseman (32)
Blocks Leader: Andrew Meshnick (32)
| DATE | AWAY TEAM | HOME TEAM | SCORE | RECORD |
| APR 18 | MADISON | INDIANAPOLIS | 26-18 | 1-0 (W) |
| APR 19 | MADISON | CINCINNATI | 23-9 | 2-0 (W) |
| APR 25 | DETROIT | MADISON | 12-35 | 3-0 (W) |
| MAY 2 | PITTSBURGH | MADISON | 18-24 | 4-0 (W) |
| MAY 15 | CHICAGO | MADISON | 13-16 | 5-0 (W) |
| MAY 22 | MINNESOTA | MADISON | 10-27 | 6-0 (W) |
| MAY 30 | MADISON | MINNESOTA | 23-18 | 7-0 (W) |
| JUN 6 | MADISON | PITTSBURGH | 22-26 | 7-1 (L) |
| JUN 7 | MADISON | DETROIT | 27-13 | 8-1 (W) |
| JUN 12 | MADISON | MINNESOTA | 31-19 | 9-1 (W) |
| JUN 19 | MADISON | CHICAGO | 23-22 | 10-1 (W) |
| JUN 20 | CHICAGO | MADISON | 16-24 | 11-1 (W) |
| JUL 12 | INDIANAPOLIS | MADISON | 24-25 | 12-1 (W) |
| JUL 17 | CINCINNATI | MADISON | 19-39 | 13-1 (W) |
| JUL 25 | PITTSBURGH | MADISON | 21-24 | 14-1 (W) |
| AUG 8 | RALEIGH | MADISON | 19-22 | 15-1 (W) |
| AUG 9 | MADISON | SAN JOSE | 15-17 | 15-2 (L) |
2016
Record: 14-0, Finished 1st in Midwest Division
Points/Game: 26.1 (4th out of 26)
Opp. Points/Game: 16.5 (1st out of 26)
Assists Leader: Peter Graffy (35)
Goals Leader: Andrew Meshnick, Brian Hart, & Colin Camp (29)
Blocks Leader: Peter Graffy (41)
| DATE | AWAY TEAM | HOME TEAM | SCORE | RECORD |
| APR 9 | MINNESOTA | MADISON | 11-25 | 1-0 (W) |
| APR 16 | MADISON | INDIANAPOLIS | 32-25 | 2-0 (W) |
| APR 30 | MADISON | PITTSBURGH | 22-18 | 3-0 (W) |
| MAY 13 | CHICAGO | MADISON | 11-18 | 4-0 (W) |
| MAY 14 | MADISON | DETROIT | 26-13 | 5-0 (W) |
| MAY 21 | CINCINNATI | MADISON | 23-36 | 6-0 (W) |
| MAY 27 | MINNESOTA | MADISON | 15-36 | 7-0 (W) |
| JUN 4 | PITTSBURGH | MADISON | 16-23 | 8-0 (W) |
| JUN 11 | DETROIT | MADISON | 19-37 | 9-0 (W) |
| JUN 17 | MADISON | MINNESOTA | 25-16 | 10-0 (W) |
| JUN 25 | MADISON | CHICAGO | 21-10 | 11-0 (W) |
| JUN 26 | MADISON | CINCINNATI | 25-22 | 12-0 (W) |
| JUL 8 | MADISON | CHICAGO | 19-16 | 13-0 (W) |
| JUL 10 | INDIANAPOLIS | MADISON | 17-23 | 14-0 (W) |
| JUL 23 | PITTSBURGH | MADISON | 16-20 | 15-0 (W) |
| AUG 6 | SEATTLE | MADISON | 26-25 | 15-1 (L) |
2017
Record: 12-2, Finished 1st in Midwest Division
Points/Game: 22.1 (17th out of 24)
Opp. Points/Game: 18.5 (1st out of 24)
Assists Leader: Andrew Meshnick (27)
Goals Leader: Colin Camp (39)
Blocks Leader: Andrew Meshnick (28)
| DATE | AWAY TEAM | HOME TEAM | SCORE | RECORD |
| APR 2 | MADISON | INDIANAPOLIS | 24-19 | 1-0 (W) |
| APR 29 | MADISON | MINNESOTA | 20-22 | 1-1 (L) |
| MAY 6 | CHICAGO | MADISON | 18-16 | 2-1 (W) |
| MAY 13 | MADISON | INDIANAPOLIS | 23-20 | 3-1 (W) |
| MAY 20 | PITTSBURGH | MADISON | 25-31 | 4-1 (W) |
| MAY 27 | CHICAGO | MADISON | 20-21 | 5-1 (W) |
| JUN 3 | DALLAS | MADISON | 23-17 | 5-2 (L) |
| JUN 10 | MADISON | MINNESOTA | 23-22 | 6-2 (W) |
| JUN 17 | MADISON | PITTSBURGH | 22-21 | 7-2 (W) |
| JUN 18 | MADISON | DETROIT | 21-11 | 8-2 (W) |
| JUN 24 | DETROIT | MADISON | 9-21 | 9-2 (W) |
| JUL 1 | MINNESOTA | MADISON | 13-21 | 10-2 (W) |
| JUL 14 | MADISON | CHICAGO | 26-17 | 11-2 (W) |
| JUL 23 | INDIANAPOLIS | MADISON | 21-22 | 12-2 (W) |
| AUG 12 | PITTSBURGH | MADISON | 22-27 | 13-2 (W) |
| AUG 26 | SAN FRANCISCO | MADISON | 23-19 | 13-3 (L) |
2018
Record: 12-2, Finished 1st in Midwest Division
Points/Game: 24.9 (3rd out of 23)
Opp. Points/Game: 17.9 (1st out of 23)
Assists Leader: Peter Graffy and Pat Shriwise (34)
Goals Leader: Peter Graffy (35)
Blocks Leader: Kevin Pettit-Scantling and Andrew Meshnick (20)
| DATE | AWAY TEAM | HOME TEAM | SCORE | RECORD |
| APR 7 | MADISON | INDIANAPOLIS | 20-13 | 1-0 (W) |
| APR 21 | MADISON | DETROIT | 27-12 | 2-0 (W) |
| APR 28 | PITTSBURGH | MADISON | 13-29 | 3-0 (W) |
| MAY 5 | MADISON | MINNESOTA | 20-19 | 4-0 (W) |
| MAY 13 | DETROIT | MADISON | 8-37 | 5-0 (W) |
| MAY 19 | MADISON | CHICAGO | 24-18 | 6-0 (W) |
| MAY 26 | RALEIGH | MADISON | 24-16 | 6-1 (L) |
| JUN 8 | MINNESOTA | MADISON | 17-20 | 7-1 (W) |
| JUN 9 | MADISON | CHICAGO | 22-21 | 8-1 (W) |
| JUN 16 | MADISON | PITTSBURGH | 25-21 | 9-1 (W) |
| JUN 17 | MADISON | INDIANAPOLIS | 20-21 | 9-2 (L) |
| JUN 30 | INDIANAPOLIS | MADISON | 17-26 | 10-2 (W) |
| JUL 3 | MINNESOTA | MADISON | 24-35 | 11-2 (W) |
| JUL 14 | CHICAGO | MADISON | 24-27 | 12-2 (W) |
| JUL 28 | INDIANAPOLIS | MADISON | 18-27 | 13-2 (W) |
| AUG 11 | LOS ANGELES | MADISON | 19-24 | 14-2 (W) |
| AUG 12 | DALLAS | MADISON | 16-20 | 15-2 (W) |
2019
Record: 6-6, Finished 5th in Midwest Division
Points/Game: 20.83 (13th out of 21)
Opp. Points/Game: 18.50 (1st out of 21)
Assists Leader: Kevin Brown (33)
Goals Leader: Colin Camp (27)
Blocks Leader: Kevin Pettit-Scantling (25)
| DATE | AWAY TEAM | HOME TEAM | SCORE | RECORD |
|
APR 14 |
MADISON | INDIANAPOLIS | 22-20 | 1-0 (W) |
| APR 20 | PITTSBURGH | MADISON | 26-17 | 2-0 (W) |
| MAY 11 | MINNESOTA | MADISON | 19-20 | 2-1 (L) |
| MAY 18 | MADISON | CHICAGO | 25-22 | 3-1 (W) |
| MAY 25 | MADISON | TORONTO | 15-22 | 3-2 (L) |
| MAY 26 | MADISON | DETROIT | 16-14 | 4-2 (W) |
| JUN 1 | INDIANAPOLIS | MADISON | 15-18 | 4-3 (L) |
| JUN 15 | MADISON | MINNESOTA | 19-21 | 4-4 (L) |
| JUN 22 | MADISON | PITTSBURGH | 20-21 | 4-5 (L) |
| JUN 28 | CHICAGO | MADISON | 18-21 | 4-6 (L) |
| JUL 6 | MINNESOTA | MADISON | 22-17 | 5-6 (W) |
| JUL 14 | DETROIT | MADISON | 33-9 | 6-6 (W) |
2021
Record: 6-6, Finished 3rd in Central Division
Points/Game: 21.4 (8th out of 22)
Opp. Points/Game: 18.5 (4th out of 22)
Assists Leader: Rami Paust (37)
Goals Leader: Kevin Pettit-Scantling (27)
Blocks Leader: Kevin Pettit-Scantling (21)
Throwing Yards Leader: Logan Pruess (2987)
Receiving Yards Leader: Rami Paust. (2251)
| DATE | AWAY TEAM | HOME TEAM | SCORE | RECORD |
|
JUN 4 |
MINNESOTA | MADISON | 19-20 | 0-1 (L) |
| JUN 5 | MADISON | DETROIT | 34-10 | 1-1 (W) |
| JUN 18 | MADISON | MINNESOTA | 19-25 | 1-2 (L) |
| JUN 20 | INDIANAPOLIS | MADISON | 24-20 | 2-2 (W) |
| JUN 27 | DETROIT | MADISON | 29-18 | 3-2 (W) |
| JUL 2 | MADISON | CHICAGO | 15-18 | 3-3 (L) |
| JUL 3 | MADISON | INDIANAPOLIS | 26-22 | 4-3 (W) |
| JUL 10 | CHICAGO | MADISON | 19-16 | 5-3 (W) |
| JUL 17 | INDIANAPOLIS | MADISON | 17-16 | 6-3 (W) |
| JUL 30 | CHICAGO | MADISON | 18-23 | 6-4 (L) |
| JUL 31 | MADISON | DETROIT | 23-15 | 7-4 (W) |
| AUG 22 | MADISON | MINNESOTA | 15-19 | 7-5 (L) |
2022
Record: 6-6, Finished 4th in Central Division
Points/Game: 19.3 (18th out of 25)
Opp. Points/Game: 19.4 (7th out of 25)
Assists Leader: Victor Luo (30)
Goals Leader: Sterling Knoche (30)
Blocks Leader: Luke Marks (14)
Throwing Yards Leader: Victor Luo (3212)
Receiving Yards Leader: Sterling Knoche (1760)
2023
Record: 4-8, Finished 5th in Central Division
Points/Game: 19.1 (T-15th out of 24)
Opp. Points/Game: 18.8 (T-10th out of 24)
Assists Leader: Henry Goldenberg (25)
Goals Leader: Anthony Gutowsky (37)
Blocks Leader: Kai DeLorenzo (13)
Throwing Yards Leader: Victor Luo (2936)
Receiving Yards Leader: Anthony Gutowsky (1636)
2024
Record: 8-4, Finished 2nd in Central Division
Points/Game: 21.1 (5th out of 24)
Opp. Points/Game: 18.1 (8th out of 24)
Assists Leader: Kai Marcus (37)
Goals Leader: Anthony Gutowsky (53)
Blocks Leader: Mitchell McCarthy (17)
Throwing Yards Leader: Kai Marcus (4130)
Receiving Yards Leader: Anthony Gutowsky (2352)
